Price Drops

Add to Cart The item has been added

EVH

Used EVH Wolfgang Special QM Chlorine Burst 2022

WAS: $999.00

Was:

Now: $949.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Gretsch

Used Gretsch Historic Series G3523 Natural 2002

WAS: $699.00

Was:

Now: $649.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Fender

Used Fender Player II Modified Stratocaster HSS Rosewood - Sunshine Yellow

WAS: $999.00

Was:

Now: $899.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Epiphone

Used Epiphone Joe Bonamassa 1955 Les Paul Standard - Copper Iridescent

WAS: $650.00

Was:

Now: $599.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Fret King

Used Fret King Country Squire Fluence Trans Blue

WAS: $599.00

Was:

Now: $549.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Reverend

Used Reverend Greg Koch Gristle ST Sunburst 2025

WAS: $1,399.00

Was:

Now: $1,199.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Reverend

Used Reverend Rick Vito Soul Agent Midnight Black 2023

WAS: $999.00

Was:

Now: $949.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Fender

Used Fender Classic Series '70s Stratocaster Natural 2002

WAS: $699.00

Was:

Now: $649.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Yamaha

Used Yamaha FG9 MX Natural 2025

WAS: $3,499.00

Was:

Now: $3,299.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Gibson

Used Gibson Kirk Hammett "Greeny” Les Paul Standard Greeny Burst 2025

WAS: $2,249.00

Was:

Now: $2,129.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

PRS

Used PRS Singlecut Ten Top Vintage Yellow 2006

WAS: $3,499.00

Was:

Now: $3,329.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

PRS

Used PRS Singlecut Ten Top Cherry Sunburst 2001

WAS: $2,999.00

Was:

Now: $2,849.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Fender

Used Fender Custom Shop '51 Nocaster NOS Vintage Blonde 2007

WAS: $2,999.00

Was:

Now: $2,849.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Reverend

Used Reverend Jetstream 290 Bigsby Midnight Black 2025

WAS: $999.00

Was:

Now: $949.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Gretsch

Vintage Gretsch Country Club 7576 Natural 1978

WAS: $2,999.00

Was:

Now: $2,849.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Gibson

Used Gibson Les Paul Classic Honey Burst 2019

WAS: $1,999.00

Was:

Now: $1,899.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Hahn

Used Hahn 228 Jim Compilongo Model "C" Blonde 2020

WAS: $2,999.00

Was:

Now: $2,849.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Northfield

Used Northfield NFMSP-A4 Mandolin Sunburst 2023

WAS: $3,199.00

Was:

Now: $3,039.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Gibson

Used Gibson Les Paul DC Double Cutaway Standard Honey Burst Flame Top 2003

WAS: $2,499.00

Was:

Now: $2,349.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Fender

Vintage Fender Coronado II Cherry 1967

WAS: $2,249.00

Was:

Now: $2,129.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Fender

Vintage Fender Telecaster Bass Blonde 1972

WAS: $3,999.00

Was:

Now: $3,799.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Gibson

Used Gibson Les Paul Traditional 120th Anniversary Cherry Sunburst 2014

WAS: $1,999.00

Was:

Now: $1,899.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Gibson

Used Gibson Custom True Historic 1957 Les Paul R7 Goldtop 2015

WAS: $5,999.00

Was:

Now: $5,699.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

G&L

Used G&L Legacy Shoreline Gold 2020

WAS: $1,199.00

Was:

Now: $1,129.00

Testimonials Guitar Background

Still in awe. Just received my used 1997 Les Paul Studio DC. It arrived in a timely manner. It was packed very well. The guitar was clean and ready to play. If fact I'm still haven't been able to put it down. It was my first time buying a used guitar but I would definitely recommend this company.

Vincent M.
I've never purchased a guitar online before, so I was bit weary at first. Boy, am I glad I purchased it through Cream City. I just received my guitar and its fantastic. I wanted to thank Paul Schell for helping with the whole process and making my purchase worry-free. I'll be coming back again for sure.

Andie L.
Buying an expensive guitar online can be a nerve racking and treacherous process -- but the purchase of my new 12 string Gretsch Country Gentleman with Cream City was a transaction beyond perfect. Brian at Cream City was extremely helpful, honest, professional and communicative -- and the guitar arrived in perfect condition two days ahead of schedule. Farewell Sweetwater, Cream City is my new go-to.

Louie M.
I have purchased two guitars from this company and the whole experience has been first class. Even down to the double box they ship the guitars in, everything is done perfectly. I really appreciate the communication and help and advice from both Bill and Andy. Not only is the service and product awesome but I really don't think you will find a better price. Its a Win Win with these guys!

Whit S.
So glad I walked in here today. Nice staff, very helpful. Wide selection of vintage guitars. Chad got me set up with my new string box and I couldn't be happier with it. Great price on my new '73 Martin D-28. Will absolutely come back here again for my music needs.

Renny D.
Okay, straight up cream city kicks a@*. I bought a tele deluxe over Internet, they worked with me to get my specific setup preferences, shipped it promptly, with great communications start to finish. I've bought and sold about 15 guitars in the last 3 years and this has been my best experience with a music shop. Highly recommend.

Stephen P.
I love this place and have been shopping here for years. They have a friendly and knowledgeable staff with a wide selection of guitars, amps, pedals and accessories. I am a professional guitar instructor in the area and I refer my students to Cream City for any of their guitar/gear/repair needs. My students always have positive things to say after shopping here as well. If you need anything guitar related, this is the place to go!

Chris K.